SP Baseload Power price (€/MWh)

SP Peak load Power price (€/MWh)

EUA price (€/t)

MIBGas price (€/MWh)

Coal Price ($/Tn)

Gas efficiency: 52%

Coal efficiency: 38%

Gas vs. Coal Price (€/MWh)

Gas efficiency: 52%

Coal efficiency: 38%

Clean Spark Spread – Baseload (€/MWh)

Clean Spark Spread – Peak load (€/MWh)

Clean Dark Spread – Baseload (€/MWh)

Clean Dark Spread – Peak load (€/MWh)

August 2022

Market Analysis

Spot and short-term contracts:

In August, Spain registered the most expensive month in the history of electricity prices. The average price of electricity on the wholesale market in August was 308,3 €/MWh, 19,3% more than in July, when it reached 258,1 €/MWh, and the most expensive month since March, when we first broke this record in 2022, according to data from the Iberian Electricity Market Operator (OMIE).

It beat all the figures seen until now, reaching up to eight daily records. But it has been from 23rd August onwards that prices have been on a downward trend, reaching an average value of 416,5 €/MWh in the last week of August, three times the figure set a year earlier.

The reason for this increase lies in the extremely high values of the gas compensation scheme (the amount gas-fired power plants operators have to be compensated with for the high cost of gas they have incurred into). This gas compensation depends on two factors: the spot price of gas and the volume of gas-fired power production. The first one has fluctuated this month between 120 and 250 €/MWh, up to 5 times the usual price, whereas the gas cap for producers’ offers is 40 €/MWh. This means that the average compensation for each MWh used has averaged 154,4 €. The second factor has not helped either. The volume of gas-fired power thermal production has also been abnormally high given the low levels of hydro production – due to the drought experienced throughout Europe – and a weak wind production.

Daily electricity demand averaged 712,2 GWh in August, approximately the same value as in June, but 6% lower if compared to July due to the high temperatures recorded during this month.

On the generation side, as previously mentioned, CCGTs have again increased their share of generation, rising from 28% of the mix as per our last report (June) to 32% this August, and followed by nuclear (21%). This increase in CCGTs generation is caused by a decrease of both wind and hydro output. Wind generation saw its share drop from 30% in June to 16% in August.

However, the share of renewable versus non-renewable energy generation continued to be 40% – 60% as coal and cogeneration have practically disappeared of the mix this month.

Regarding gas prices (MIBGAS), a strong upward trend was observed during the second half of August, reaching historical records of more than 200 €/MWh for 6 days in a row. This rise has been even stronger in European countries where there is a greater dependence on Russian gas, and mainly due to Gazprom’s announcement that it would stop pumping gas to Germany from 31 August for three days for maintenance reasons. TTF prices have exceeded 300 €/MWh. In this context, Spain imported gas through the VIP Pyrenees gas pipeline – the gas interconnection with France – every day of August despite the fact that it has been exporting gas to the rest of its European partners since the start of the war. According to the August operating plan published by Enagás, Spain has imported almost 3,000 GWh of gas via VIP Pirineos Done with one objective in mind: to increase gas storage for the winter, Spain has been allowed to do so because Europe has already fulfilled its obligations to have its gas storage facilities 80% full, the objective being to have them full by 1 November.

The Minister Teresa Ribera has met with Iberdrola and with representatives of the Spanish Gas Association (Sedigas) and the Spanish Electricity Association (Aelec) to gather proposals that will help Spain reduce its gas consumption with the aim of designing the Contingency Plan that the Government must send to Brussels.

Along with gas, CO2 prices rose sharply, and each recorded a new all-time high this month. This led to a price increase of around 30% in most European electricity markets. The closing price (EUA spot) reached on Friday 19th  of 98.01 €/Tn is the highest ever recorded, surpassing the highest prices reached just before the start of the war in Ukraine.

In the news, if this price scenario is scary in Spain, it is even worse in the rest of Europe. Both Germany and France have reached daily electricity prices of 700 €/MWh in the last week of August. Faced with this crisis, the President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, announced on August 29th that the European Union is preparing some emergency measures to curb the soaring electricity prices. And an extraordinary meeting of the Energy Council has been convened in Brussels, with the participation of EU Energy Ministers, for September 9th.

Medium- and long-term contracts:

Moreover, forecasts for the future are not encouraging either: The high prices seen for gas, CO2 and, thus, electricity are not likely to change immediately. The market is forecasting a very harsh winter in Europe, especially in the main markets of France and Germany.

Concerning Spain, gas futures (MIBGas Cal23) absorbed what was seen in the spot market, with the contract exceeding 200 €/MWh on 19 August and remaining above this value throughout the rest of August. However, despite this high price, our country will not run out of gas, as there are enough LNG contracts with the regasification plants to ensure our supply throughout the winter. Spain has met the target set by Brussels three months in advance. This requirement of the EC has obliged Member States to fill their underground storage facilities to at least 80% of their capacity by 31 October. This target has already been achieved by Poland, Sweden, Denmark, Belgium, the Czech Republic, Portugal and France. Our reserves have already reached 81% of their capacity. Still, Spain needs to continue filling its storage facilities as much as possible for the winter in case it is necessary to help other European partners during the colder months.

On the other hand, this storage figure will not be sufficient to cover demand, so further savings will have to be made. In the case of Germany, households consuming gas will be charged a levy; for its part, the UK is preparing for possible supply cuts and for the price to double.

As far as CO2 futures on the EEX market are concerned, the benchmark December 2022 contract exceeded an average price of 90 €/Tn this month.

The Spanish electricity forward market absorbs the panic shown by the spot market and the fear of gas shortages for the coming winter. The average price in August for the next Q4-2022 was 193 €/MWh, reaching a peak value of 265 €/MWh on August 26th. The OMIP Cal2023 reached values of c. 350 €/MWh during the last week of the month and dropped on August 31st to close the month at a value of 258,5 €/MWh. The gas compensation price, in force until May 2023, should then be added to these values.

During August, on the one hand, front-month Brent crude oil futures recorded an average closing price of above 97 $/bbl. This represents a decrease of 7% when compared to the previous month’s average price. The low of the month was reached on Tuesday 16th, when the closing price was 92.34 $/bbl. On the other hand, the average price for 2023 during August has remained the same as in July (around 90 $/bbl) but has decreased with regards to the upward trend seen in June (around 100 $/bbl).

This drop in Brent prices is strongly associated with fears of a possible economic recession, particularly in China and the United States, following the communication by the International Monetary Fund warning that the world economy faces increasingly uncertain circumstances as the three major world economies (China, the United States and Europe) show signs of stagnation amid the consequences of the war in Ukraine.

Suscribe to our Newsletter

Each month, one of our experts publishes an article describing his view on a specific topic of the constant changes taking place in the energy market, with special focus on the French market.

S'abonner à notre newsletter

Chaque mois, un de nos experts publie un article décrivant son point de vue sur un sujet spécifique choisi parmi les changements constants affectant le marché de l’énergie, avec un focus particulier sur le marché français.

Expérience professionnelle

Céline, jeune active dynamique, a fait ses premiers pas dans le monde du travail dans le domaine du tourisme en tant que community manager au Loups du Gévaudan, en Lozère. En rejoignant l’équipe HES en novembre 2021, elle a souhaité diversifier ses connaissances : se former dans le secteur énergétique, se spécialiser dans les stratégies marketing afin de développer les relations clients de l’entreprise ; tout en approfondissant ses compétences en coordination et gestion de projets.

Formation

Céline est diplômée d’une double licence Espagnole – Anglais en Langue, Littérature et Civilisation Etrangère à la Sorbonne IV (2018). Elle a aussi obtenu un Master II en Direction de Projets ou Etablissements Culturel, spécialité Tourisme International. Elle a également étudié à l’étranger, à University of London (Angleterre) et Universidad de Morón (Argentine).

Céline Haya Sauvage

Responsable Marketing

DSC_0323
« La décarbonisation des secteurs de l’énergie et des transports est sans doute aujourd’hui le principal moteur économique de l’industrie. »

Expérience professionnelle

Il a débuté sa carrière dans le génie civil en tant que chef de projet en France, en Martinique et en Australie. Par la suite, il devient directeur général d’une filiale au Venezuela. En 1992, il crée une filale pour Dalkia en Allemagne (chauffage urbain, cogénération et partenariats) et représente Véolia en Thaïlande. En 2000, il a ouvert le bureau commercial d’Endesa en France pour profiter de la libéralisation du marché de détail. A partir de 2006, en tant que responsable du développement chez Endesa France, il a dirigé le plan d’Endesa pour la production à cycle combiné gaz en France et a simultanément développé le portefeuille éolien et photovoltaïque de la Snet. Philippe Boulanger a ensuite travaillé pendant 3 ans au siège d’E.ON pour coordonner les activités de l’entreprise en France. Il a été fortement impliqué dans le projet français de renouvellement de la concession hydroélectrique. En tant que Senior Vice President – Project Director chez Solvay Energy Services d’avril 2012 à février 2014, il était en charge des projets de déploiement H2/Power to gas et d’accès direct au marché européen. Philippe est un expert pour HES depuis 2014.

Formation

Philippe Boulanger est ingénieur diplômé de l’Ecole Polytechnique et de l’Ecole Nationale des Ponts & Chaussées (France) et possède une expérience combinée de plus de 25 ans en énergie et infrastructures. En plus de l’anglais, M. Boulanger parle couramment le français, l’allemand et l’espagnol.

Philippe Boulanger

Electricity Expert

HES-Philippe-Boulanger
« Le monde est en train de changer. De nouveaux investisseurs accordent une attention particulière au secteur de l’énergie alors que les acteurs historiques adaptent leur position sur le marché. »

Expérience professionnelle

Antonio a commencé sa carrière dans le secteur de l’électricité en 1991 en tant que membre de l’équipe du directeur général de Sevillana de Electricidad (Espagne). En 1997, il était responsable de la réglementation commerciale chez Endesa Distribution. En 2000, il rejoint le département M&A européen d’Endesa. Il a été nommé CEO d’Endesa Power Trading Ltd en 2003. En 2004, il devient Directeur de la gestion de l’énergie de la SNET (France) et en 2008, il est nommé Directeur Général de cette société. En 2009, il a occupé le poste de Directeur du Développement Entreprise d’E.ON France. En 2011, il a fondé Haya Energy Solutions (HES), une société de conseil qui aide les entreprises à optimiser leur chaîne de valeur : de la définition de la stratégie aux opérations quotidiennes, en s’appuyant sur une solide expérience et une bonne compréhension de l’industrie de l’énergie. De 2015 à 2018, Antonio a été Président de Celest qui opère 2 CCGT françaises (420MW chacune), détenues par KKR. Fin 2018, il rejoint Asterion Industrial Partners, un fonds d’investissement dédié aux infrastructures, en tant que partenaire opérationnel.

Formation

Ingénieur industriel de l’Ecole Supérieure d’Ingénieurs de Séville (Espagne) et titulaire d’un MBA de Deusto (Espagne).

Antonio Haya

CEO